Utley Kinsler Trade WHIR

[williscubs]

I'm in a 16-team 20 keeper league with offensive categories AVG, R, HR, RBI, SB, and OPS.
The deal is:
I trade Ian Kinsler and Jose Tabata for Chase Utley
Would you make the trade?

My roster is:
C. McCann
1B. Sandoval
2B. Kinsler
3B. Wright
SS. Reyes
OF. Kemp
OF. J. Upton
OF. B.J. Upton
UTIL. CarGo
UTIL. Bruce
UTIL. Andrus
B. Tabata
B. Bautista
DL. Beltran
DL. Morales

Thanks and let me know to which thread you want me to respond!

[IronBird]

In a heartbeat. Kinsler is sweet while he's hot, but he is guaranteed to get hurt. Probably even one more time this season. Coming from an owner of Kinsler for the last 3 years, I like him, but with his tailed off batting avg. I'd take Utley over him for sure.

[mshimmyb]

I would do it also... Utley is slumping right now, but he's gonna turn it around...

please help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=415108

[baegames]

Long term, I would take Utley over Kinsler. Tabata is just gravy. Take the deal.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=415062

[royalty]

no doubt, Utley is the guy to have here. Philly's offense will turn it on at some point this year and Utley in the middle of the lineup will be sweet to have.