Debate.... Butler Vs Beltre

[lbbaseball14]

Who would you guys rather have for the remainder of the year? I personally think Butler will outproduce him when its all said and done but would not be particularly suprised to see Beltre get the best of him. Better lineup, better park and swinging a hot bat. What do you guys think?

[mojoorising]

I think butler will put up slightly better numbers but i rather have beltre due to 3b eligible

[skjelstrom]

I think Beltre is having a GREAT season but his avg will definitely fall. he just isn't that good of an average player. I think his power can stay around but I think Butler will catch Beltres HR numbers really quick. Id take Butler the rest of the year as he can definitely maintain a high avg and his hard liners and really close doubles are a sign that he is just getting a little unlucky with power numbers. But with Beltres 3B eligibility he was a great draft this year and a great player so far.