Tulo and Cliff Lee for Halladay and.....WHIR

[MarkakisMVP]

I get
Halladay
Carlos Gonzalez
Tejada

I give
Tulo
Cliff Lee

Is Carlos an upgrade over my current OF of Abreu, Magglio, Markakis with Soriano and Rajai Davis on the bench?

Batters
H R 3B HR RBI BB SB AVG OBP SLG
Lineup: Napoli, D Lee, Prado, Tulo, Wright, Markakis, Abreu, Magglio, Pena
Bench: Soriano, Bautisia, R Davis, Roberts DL
Pitchers
IP W L SV SVOP K ERA WHIP K/9 QS
SP: C Lee, Vazquez, Shields, Dempster, Latos, Cueto
RP: Feliz, Capps, Lidge
Bench: CJ Wilson