Which outfielder to add?

[jamesmeg]

I need to add an OF for a non keeper league team.

Here are the people available on the wire I am thinking about:

Luke Scott
Jose Guillen
Fred Lewis
Seth Smith
Andres Torres
Sean Rodriguez
Tyler Colvin
Jose Tabata

I am short in all categories so really it doesn't matter what categories i improve in, i just want the best total value for the player. Right now I am thinking about Colvin or Tabata because I like their upside. Who do you think I should add?

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i like Colvin as long as Lou lets him play like he said

[mshimmyb]

I like Colvin as well... but in yahoo leagues Scott can also play 1B and Rodriguez can also play 2B.... so take that in consideration if your lacking in either of those positions... but if not I would pick up Colvin.

please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=414935

[Chief Wahoo]

I love Colvin as long as Lou keeps playing him. Rodriguez's regular time is coming to an end with Bartlett returning. Scott is too hot and cold for my taste. The others are just so-so. Colvin has to be the choice if he gets some burn.

[k.k.]

Tabata hasn't disappointed since getting called up. I'd probably try him out.

[michaelyoung4prez]

i really like torres the most, he has guaranteed playing time, decent lineup and could be a 5 category guy

[BUCCOFAN]

I'd rank them in this order.

Torres - hitting leadoff
Tabata - ditto
Colvin - starting to play everyday, if he solidifies a RF spot, bump him ahead of Tabata

PLEASE HELP ME:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=414965

[sweettortilla]

I'd rank them in this order.

Torres - hitting leadoff
Tabata - ditto
Colvin - starting to play everyday, if he solidifies a RF spot, bump him ahead of Tabata

Agree with this 100%

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=415057