McGehee for Leake? WHIR

[tomman710]

I play in a 6X6 H2H keeper league ... here is my team:

C - Soto, G. (K)
1B - Gonzales, A.
2B - Phillips, B. (K)
3B - Longoria, E. (K)
SS - Andrus, E.
OF - Hamilton, J. (K)
OF - Either, A.
OF - Lee, C.
UTL - Butler, B.
Bench - McGehee, C., Stubbs, D.

SP - Halladay, R.
SP - Lincecum, T.
SP - Hanson, T. (K)
SP - Marcum, S.
SP - Kuroda, H.
SP - Kennedy, I.
SP - Medlen, K.
SP - Francis, J.

RP - Soriano, R.
RP - Gregg, K.

I am currently in the top three but the other teams in the top three have a little deeper pitching staff. Leake would be eligible to be a keeper after this season but my question is does this make me better AND will Leake be shut down come playoff time for me? Is this a good trade?

WHIR

[coma]

I wouldn't do it. Leake is a rook and has shown that he can implode at any time. McGehee has been a pleasant surprise this year, I would aim a little higher.

HIR: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=414868