Deal Hamilton...?

[corcam22]

Been offered Clay Bucholz/Bourn for Hamilton/Zambrano. I'm at the top for power, last in SB's. Middle of the pack in wins. What do you all think?

C-Molina
C-Cervelli
1B- Sandoval
2B- Uggla
3B- Zimmerman
SS- Bartlett
MI- McGhee
CI- Longoria
OF- Hamilton
OF- Bautista
OF- Ethier
OF- Stubbs
OF- Pierre
U- Howard

P- E. Jackson
P- Cliff Lee
P- A.J. Burnett
P- Zambrano
P- D. Price
P-Strasburg
RP- Hoffman
RP- Jenks
RP- Guerrier

[fitz0527]

I think you can get more for Hamilton than that.

[Hes So Taguchi]

I agree. He looks like he's returning to form.

[Surfs up]

Agree. Get more

[mshimmyb]

no way!!! Hamilton is much more valuable!! Maybe a Jose Reyes?

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=94&t=414849

[corcam22]

O.K. He's sweetened the deal by offering Liriano for my choice of pitcher. So the deal now would be Bourn/Bucholz/Liriano for Hamilton, Zambrano and one of my other pitchers. Do I take the deal now?

[Montana168]

i still wouldnt do that deal. you should be able to get those 3 for hamilton alone. but that deal would make your OF very weak and i don't think you need the SP that bad. with the way hamilton is hitting you should be able to get liriano and quality bat back. good luck.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=414857

[corcam22]

Just to clarify our league rules: 4 x 4 (no runs, no K's). We have to trade position for position, always keeping a 23 man roster (14 hit/9 pit). If I did make the trade, would it be an absolute "Dumba** of the year? Liriano and Bucholz are both cheap going into next year and years after (keeper league). Hamilton is in his 2nd to last year. I just think I have to make a move for SB's before I'm really out of the race. Liriano/Bucholz wins/ERA/Whip would also help me maintain and possibly gain some pts. Help!!!

[corcam22]

Any more thoughts? Any advice is worth the input....no matter how trivial you think it is. Thanks for your help.