I for sure would take the Reyes side. He has been looking really good for a few weeks and is inching closer every day to where he was 2 years ago. Reyes has never had an injury problem outside of last year, so there is no real reason to think he is injury prone. As a matter of fact he has always been top 5 in the league in games played and at-bats, so he's actually proven to be very durable in his career.
Reyes still has first round upside. go with him.
Thanks for the imput on mine