Jason Werth for my Jimmy Rollins? *WHIR*

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

Proposed trade to me:

i give: Rollins
i get: J.Werth

I'm thinking of a counter that would include on of my 1B and free up some roster space. what about....

i give: Rollins + Berkman + Bailey
i get: Werth + R.Dempster + Dotel

(EDIT: counter was rejected, original offer still stands)


His roster:
c: M.Napoli
1b: M.Teixeira / J.Cantu
2b: B.Phillips
3b: K.Youkilis
ss: E.Aybar
OF: A.MCutchen / I.Suzuki / M.Kemp / J.Werth
SP: R.Nolasco / J.Lackey / L.Hernandez / R.Dempster / B.Zito / M.Pelfrey / W.Rodriguez / C.Silva / J.Jurrjens
RP: A.Bailey / N.Feliz / M.Capps


10 team - H2H- 6x6 - nonkeeper - daily changes - max adds per week = 3
(R,HR,RBI,AVG,OBP,SB --- W,QS, SV,K,ERA,WHIP)

C-Buster Posey (c/1b)
1B-Albert Pujols (1b)
2B-Alberto Callaspo (2b/3b)
3B-Mark Reynolds (1b/3b)
SS-Yunel Escobar (ss)
OF-Andre Ethier (of)
OF-Ryan Ludwick (of)
OF-Jay Bruce (of)
Util-Joey Votto (1b)
BN-David Ortiz (1b)
BN-Lance Berkman (1b)
BN-Michael Stanton (of)
DL-Jimmy Rollins (ss)

SP-Yovani Gallardo
SP-John Lester
RP-Carlos Marmol
RP-Rafael Soriano
P-Octavio Dotel
P-Matt Garza
P-Francisco Liriano
BN-AJ Burnett
BN-Clay Buchholz

[Shermanator]

You need to consider J Roll's injury. He is not that close to returning. At least two weeks out. And when he does, he's going to take it slow, meaning no stolen bases.
So to me, Werth straight up, or that counter you are proposing, sounds good to me

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

bump

[Seanyfever]

Shermator summed it up for me.

Share your three cents!
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=414688

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

any more opinions?

[Montana168]

i agree with the above posts. i would do that deal just because rollins' injury puts his status too much in the air and werth is a nice 30/20 option in the OF. although, with the way your team looks, i would make that deal and try to see if you can trade an OF with yunel escobar and see if you can get an upgrade at OF, good luck.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=414857

[footballisbetter.com]

I agree with Montana. JRoll is still a question mark and he will certainly be slow out of the gate. So I wouldn't expect him to run nearly as much. I would definitely go for this trade because Werth is a stud. But...I would then look to see if you can make another deal for another SS. Possibly shop a Berkman or Big Papi to upgrade. Y Escobar isn't an ideal SS in a 10 team league. Someone must have 2 good SS's on their roster.

see mine? viewtopic.php?t=414829

[philaphan]

Completely agree with the others. I would do the deal stright up Rollins for Werth. This may be an injury that lingers or plays with Rollins head. I don't think Rollins will run a lot when he gets back and you should get more out of Werth for the rest of the year.

Please help me
viewtopic.php?t=414864