trade help WHIR

[senioroctober051]

i give miggy cabrera and get dunn carpenter and silva

it is a keeper league and the other guy is pretty much packin it in for the season and looking for better keepers

the rest of my team looks like this

mccann
cabrera
cano
tulo
stephen drew
wigginton
werth
damon
heyward
pierre
aramis ramirez
ellsbury
buster posey

wandy
leake
hochevar
blackburn
jason vargas
kazmir
bailey
valverde
contreras
tim hudson
millwood
livan hernandez
brett cecil
brett anderson
brandon webb

the stat categories are runs, home runs, rbis, sb, avg, obp, slg, ip, wins, complete games, saves, ks, era and whip
thanks in advance

[Shermanator]

Eh, I think its fair. But close.
I would want more for Cabrera personally. He's a top 3 player this year. You could use pitching help. So you may want to consider this. But it doesnt blow me away

[senioroctober051]

thanks for the response.

if i tried to throw in cain instead of silva do you think it would be a better trade for me?

[Singles]

I agree, it seems fair and evenish but I'm not wowed either. I think you can get better pitching for Cabrera. Look for a good bat with a top SP.





viewtopic.php?t=414675

[senioroctober051]

and the deal gets a little more interesting..

the deal is now my miggy and ellsbury for dunn, carpenter, cain, and soria

im having trouble parting with miggy since this is a keeper league (sorry i forgot to mention that earlier) and he is a top three player this year

[Seatownfavorite]

I don't think you have enough offense to win without Miggy, and although your pitching could use a facelift I still don't think I would do it. The new offer is very tempting. How many keepers are we talking here? Cabrera is the only first round talent I see.


On a side note, you asked about my dynasty league setup. We started as long time redraft, then decide to increase keepers by 5 each year and now we just keep 25 per team each season. We don't have contacts or anything like that.

[senioroctober051]

it is a five player keeper league.

i was thinking that if i did trade miggy, i would keep cano, heyward, tulo, maybe posey? and potentially carpenter or cain?

im really up in the air about this trade, i just feel like im getting so much pitching back and dunn would semi replace the home runs of miggy

[senioroctober051]

one final question for this trade

the other teams roster is as follows

wieters
billy butler
kelly johnson
david freese
mike aviles
michael bourn
mike stanton
dunn
konerko
cuddyer
chris young-the outfield
jay bruce and brad hawpe

in addition to matt cain chris carpenter and soria, is there anyone other than dunn, or a combination of other players to make trading miggy and ellsbury worth it?

thanks for the help