J Shields/Berkman or J Johnson/Smoak? WHIR

[footballisbetter.com]

Which side would you rather have? James Shields + Berkman or Josh Johnson + Smoak?

Basically I woulld be trading (proposing) Shields and Berkman for Johnson. Then I would pick up Smoak since he was dropped last week. Thoughts? Leave a link

My team
C- Posada
C- M Montero
1st- Berkman
3rd- Youkilis
CI- G Jones
SS- Y Escobar
2nd- Cano
MI- Weeks
OF (4)- CarGo, Ethier, Victorino, Granderson
U- BJ Upton
Pitcher (9)- Felix, Hughes, Danks, Shields, Slowey, I Kennedy, Gregg, F Cordero, Corpas
Bench (3)- P Alvarez, Heilman, Wandy
Dl- M Gonzalez

[dubstar]

Go for Johnson,, then add Smoak. Not sure if he will accept it, Johnson has been sick.

[coma]

I'd take the Johnson side. The guy has been playing like a beast.

Thanks for the help.

[MrToilet]

I would do this trade too, Johnson is pitching really well this year - basically you're giving up Shields for Johnson and I think picking up someone to get 80-85% of Berkman's stats (or better) shouldn't be too hard on the wire.

Thanks for your help too!

[sha]

yea...not too high on berkman this season. johnson is big upgrade over shields and you will get a decent stick in smoak. go for it!
help me?
viewtopic.php?t=414526

[Emerald8h]

I'd do it for Johnson. He's clearly the best player in that deal.

[Surfs up]

JJ side 100%