STRASBURG for 6 players?? NEED HELP!

[RollTide13]

I am in a standard 5 x 5 head to head yahoo league.
This is my team:
C Yadier Molina
1B Lance Berkman
2B Pedrioa
SS Jeter
3b M. Young
OF victorino
OF upton
OF Ichiro
Util Vlad
BN A. Soriano
BN Manny
BN Carlos Pena
I play manny Pena and soriano alot on best matchups with my players day by day

SPCain
SPGrienke
RPMarmol
RPjenks
P Latos
P lilly
P Strasburg
BN Gio Gonzalez
DL Brad Penny
DL Alfredo Simon

This is an annual league where we can KEEP UP TO 5 Players for the next season.

I was offered for Strasburg:

Werth
Carpenter
Lidge
Rauch
Kershaw
Lester

Any advice is appreciated!

[fitz0527]

Yeah, I 'd definitely deal Strasburg for those 6 guys.

[Jenken]

are you kidding me? how is this even debateable

obviously do it,this is embarassingly bad for the other guy

[LARS929]

Do the trade in a heart-beat, Strasburg isn't as good as most of those guys alone!

[fitz0527]

This is a funny thread

[Jenken]

Im actually leaning towards no... Carpenter, Werth, Lester and Kershaw do not match the one start phenom in Strasburg. Not a chance.

[RollTide13]

I have to drop three players...gio gonzalez, carlos pena and who else?

[Jenken]

Soriano

[RollTide13]

Take that back have to drop four

[RyeWhiskey]

Well since you have to drop 4 it boils down to this:

Werth
Carpenter
Lester
Kershaw
Rauch
Lidge

for

Strasburg
A Soriano
G Gonzalez
Pena
Manny

So you're looking at:
Werth > Soriano
Lester =< Strasburg
Carpenter >> Gonzalez
Kershaw > Pena
Rauch, Lidge = Manny

But then you'd be keeping: Pedroia, J Upton, Ichiro, Werth, Lester. So the question is, would you rather keep Werth and Lester, or Cain/Grienke and Strasburg?