Adrian Gonzalez/Zobrist for Oswalt/Dunn/Pena?

[islandflyfisher]

Would you accept? I know what I think, but there is one reason I am having second thoughts. I would like to know what you guys think before I explain why I am hesitating.

[islandflyfisher]

I should add that I am in a 4 keeper league with Mauer, Howard, Carpenter and Werth as probable Keepers.
My current roster is:
C: Mauer
1B: Howard
2B: Uggla
3B: Cantu
SS: Furcal, Alex Gonzalez
IF: Pena, Figgins
OF: Werth
OF: Lind
OF: Dunn
OF: Stanton, Coghlan

SP: Carpenter
SP: Johnson
SP: Oswalt
SP: Marcum
SP: Neimann
SP: Jaime Garcia
SP: Latos
RP: Axford
RP: Nunez
RP: Rivera

Brandon Webb is currently in FA, so if I make the trade, I could pick him up and stash him in my DL spot, then pick up Lilly, Braden, Cecil or Fister.

My main concern is that I am selling Pena low and buying Zobrist high.

[mekman20]

Pena will always have a low average. You're not buying high on Zobrist, either...he was great last year...if anything you're getting him low. Assuming you can bear the loss of Oswalt at SP, I'd do it. Zobrist would take Pena's IF spot, and your team already has good power... so you're upgrading there-- then it's Oswalt/Dunn for Adrian, which is close. I take it.

[somervillesoxfan]

Id do it. Zobrist should turn it around and Gonzalez is a beast. Pena and Dunn are good for HRs and Oswalt is always an injury risk. I say do it and scour the wire for another SP.


thanks for helping on mine
viewtopic.php?t=414332