Pick up Madison Bumgarner Drop Nasty Nate McLouth?

[Neboguy]

After Bruce Bochey's latest comment that Bumgarner is "real close" to earning a promotion, I picked up Madison Bumgarner and dropped Nasty Nate McLouth. Good move or bad?

14 Team Non-Keeper League (Re-Draft)

Stat Master Stat

C-Mike Napoli
C-Max Ramirez
1B-Justin Smoak
2B-Brandon Phillips
SS-Hanley Ramirez
3B-Mark Reynolds
MI-Sean Rodriguez
CL-Derrek Lee
OF-Nick Markakis
OF-Josh Hamilton
OF-Seth Smith
OF-Mike Stanton
OF-Juan Pierre
DH-Curtis Granderson
P-John Ely
P-Javier Vazquez
P-David Price
P-Brad Lincoln
P-Brett Cecil
P-Johnny Cueto
P-Heath Bell
P-Rafeal Soriano
P-Ben Sheets

Bench
1B-Adam LaRoche
SP-Madison Bumgarner
SP-Carl Pavano
SP-Kris Medlen
SP-Freddy Garcia


DL
SP Brett Anderson
SP Edinson Volquez
SS Jimmy Rollins
2B Eric Young Jr.