Quick! Which C to hang onto? WHIR!!!

[woowoo crew]

Keeper 12 team league. I have 2 catchers: Napoli and Posey. I am going to offer one up in a 2 for 1 trade to try and get Rios. Which one to offer and which one to keep on my team?

[zonk]

If you can't keep Posey as a Utility, then trade him and keep Napoli. Nap is the top ranked catcher (More Runs, HRs and RBIs than any other catcher) over the last month and Posey doesn't have the power potential or the offensive lineup that Nap offers.

[woowoo crew]

bumping up...

[saemick]

I'd keep Napoli in the short term, but Posey in the long term. Yes Napoli has bees doing really well, but he always seems to get hurt. Also, he is a pretty streaky player. As for Posey, he won't have the power that Napoli possesses, but he will keep hitting for average and drive in runs...which isn't something you can say about most catchers. Not to mention they're playing Posey at 1st in addition to Catcher, so he should get more playing time as well.

Thanks for helping with mine.

[soty]

If you can keep Posey (keeper) and trade Napoli as part of a deal for Rios then you should jump all over that.

[zonk]

On second thought, I like soty's reply better. Ignore my response.