Weaver for Jeter - WHIR

[gentlemanjerseydave]

Always get great help on this board.

I am in a deep keeper league. My offense is hurting and I need a solid consistent bat. I am platooning Furcal/Aviles at SS and it is the easiest position for me to upgrade. I have a lot of SPs.

I have been offered to send Jered Weaver for Jeter.

Would you make this trade?

I realize Weaver is a better keeper long term but I am in competition this season and want to make moves that can bring me a title. This move will leave me with:
Hughes
Romero
Ely
Leake
Burnett
and
Colby Lewis/Doug Fister as spot starters

I also have Bedard and Webb on the DL but lets ignore them.

[gentlemanjerseydave]

Bump - I know someone here has an opinion.
Thanks.

[fierro33]

id do this......u gain on value here.....i like weaver but jeter is a top ss

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=413932

[Guzman24]

I think you win the deal. Id do it.

It does leave your staff a bit thin but hopefully Hughes and Romero can keep it up.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=413934

[gentlemanjerseydave]

Thanks.
My pitching staff is in the top three of my 15 team keeper league and I am already 100 innings over the pace on the season limit. It is best for me to dish a pitcher anyway since come September they will be used sparingly.

[LARS929]

I would do the trade. No offense, but your pitching is a little weak, so losing Weaver will hurt. but IMO I would rather have all mediocre SPs and great hitting anyway over the one ace and mediocrity.

viewtopic.php?t=413859