Huge Trade -- Big Names -- WHIR

[theinflatinator91]

Would you make this trade? 12 team head to head league. 12 x 12 stat categories will be listed below.

batting runs, hits, doubles, triples, hr, rbi, steals, walks, avg, obp, slg, plate appearances
pitching ip, wins, complete games, shutouts, saves, hits, er, walks, k, era, whip, k/9

The trade: Russel Martin, Prince Fielder, Mark Reynolds, Curtis Granderson, and Jake Peavy for Michael Young, Hanley Ramirez, Jayson Werth, and Jonathan Sanchez(I recieve underlined players)

My Current Roster:
C Buster Posey
1B Prince Fielder
2B Ian Kinsler
3B Mark Reynolds
SS Ben Zobrist
OF B.J. Upton
OF Justin Upton
OF José Bautista
Util Franklin Gutiérrez
Util Russell Martin
BN Casey McGehee
BN Curtis Granderson
BN Carlos Quentin
BN Troy Glaus
BN Plácido Polanco

SP Chad Billingsley
SP Colby Lewis
SP Ubaldo Jiménez
SP Brett Anderson
SP Max Scherzer
RP Leo Núñez
RP Matt Thornton
P Brett Cecil
P Jake Peavy
DL Jorge De La Rosa

What do you think? Should I try to counter and snag another player? If so who? Some notables include Ellsbury, Dunn, and Nolasco...

[Celtics31]

wow...i really dont know it is all so dependent on Hanley heating up. I think i would maybe stay put even though as a fellow Reynolds owner I am concerned about his quad

[outsideoftime]

Reynolds will be fine. He tweaks this same injury all the time and plays fine with it. It just keeps him from stealing bases and going first to third. His manager thinks he can play through it with a DL stint and Lord knows they need his bat right now.

Still I like this trade...Hanely always has hot summers and Werth is a stud.

Although Fielder typically has hot summers too.

[krunchyfrogg]

You're getting Hanley Ramierez, and not overpaying. Anytime this criteria is met, you've got to go for it.

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=413897

[pnoozi]

Don't counter. Accept. You're not addressing any sort of categorical need (although losing Reynolds for Young will really help your average). You're just overall improving from this trade.

[gentlemanjerseydave]

I'd take this trade. Fielder has me a bit concerned and you are getting a great value for him in this deal. Your team is taking on Werth who I'm high on and Hanley who needs no explanation. Your team instantly gets better. Take it.