Holliday & Kemp Keeper Trade

[RenT]

Which side? 14 team roto keeper league.

A. Holliday, Hamilton, E. Aybar

or

B. Kemp, Stephen Drew

[RenT]

No one with a quick A or B? Leave a link, I'll reply to yours ASAP

[grandpa]

Thanks for mine- I like A better, not a big Drew fan

[redsoxsucker]

How long can you keep them for? Kemp is clearly best player here but I'm not sure that overall the balance of value doesn't go the Holliday route

[RenT]

You can keep them forever... the only catch is the amount of keepers depends on where you finish. The top few teams keep 6, then the next few 7, then 8 until the last few teams keep 10. If the value is that lopsided toward Holliday and Hamilton would it be better to substitute Markakis in for Hamilton? Or is that too big of a downgrade? I'm trying to get Kemp here and realize I have to give up a lot, but really don't want to give up too much. Thanks for the help so far.

[jweb2244]

I happen to be a big Holliday fan, especially in that lineup, so I would take A.

Thanks for help on mine.

[jdip5]

B. Markakis would make the deal even for me

[MLB2010]

a all the way

[JonGrudenRocks]

i like A because Holliday should turn is season around and Hamilton is better than Drew