Roy Halladay for Matt Kemp and Matt Cain?!!

[mmeye19]

Only a 4 Team League, 5x5 Roto, the trade offered is my Roy Halladay for his Matt Cain and Matt Kemp.

My current roster:
C: Brian McCann
1B: Justin Morneau / Billy Butler
2B: Ben Zobrist / Kelly Johnson
3B: Ryan Zimmerman
SS: Hanley Ramirez / Jimmy Rollins (DL)
OF: Carl Crawford / Justin Upton / Jason Bay / Bobby Abreu / Alex Rios / Shin-Soo Choo/ Hunter Pence / Michael Bourn / Magglio Ordonez / Juan Pierre / Carlos Beltran (DL)
DH: Vladimir Guerrero
SPs: Tim Lincecum / Roy Halladay / Zach Greinke / Felix Hernandez / Yovani Gallardo / Dan Haren / Clayton Kershaw / Johan Santana / James Shields
RPs: Mariano Rivera / Jonathan Papelbon / Joakim Soria / Matt Capps / Neftali Feliz

His roster:
C: Joe Mauer
1B: Miguel Cabrera
2B: Chase Utley / Martin Prado / Placido Polanco
3B: Pablo Sandoval / Scott Rolen / Adrian Beltre
SS: Troy Tulowitzki
OF: Matt Kemp / Ichiro Suzuki / Jayson Werth / Shane Victorino / Vernon Wells / Denard Span / Scott Podsednik / Alfonso Soriano / Austin Jackson
SP: Cliff Lee / Adam Wainwright / Justin Verlander / Ubaldo Jimenez / Chad Billingsley / Cole Hamels / Matt Cain / David Price / Barry Zito
RP: Jonathan Broxton / Carlos Marmol / Rafael Soriano / Ryan Franklin / David Aardsma / Huston Street (DL)

Please help! Thanks a bunch!

[wedgedbacks]

I think that's a trade you do. You'll lose some Ks but the tradeoff of getting a slightly lesser pitcher and a great outfielder is hard to pass up.

Hit me back?

viewtopic.php?t=413813

[dagactor]

By all means take that trade. Hitting over pitching (I'd take Kemp straight for Doc) and Cain is no slouch. Congrats!

[redsoxsucker]

Hit accept QUICKLY!!! That's a great deal for you...

Please help:
viewtopic.php?t=413821

[k.k.]

I agree with everyone else. Make the deal. You can't lose getting solid Cain in for Halladay, and then with the Kemp bonus, which is HUGE.

[Singles]

Excellent trade for you. As someone already stated, Halladay for Kemp alone would be a great deal for you. Nice move.


viewtopic.php?t=413827

[DKuon]

Kemp has been hitting very well and is exceeding expectations. Cain is a very good pitcher, probably a #2 pitcher in the Giant's rotation. I think that you should do this trade.


Help?
viewtopic.php?t=413624

[baegames]

I'm going to have to say probably not, depending. As you say, it is a 4 team league. My question is how many OF you start.

If you are starting Michael Bourn, by all means, make the deal.

If the worst OF you are starting is Shin-Soo Choo or Bobby Abreu, I say pass.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=413835