Gardner/Markakis for McCutchen/LaRoche?

[boyogold]

Not the most glamorous of trades, but would appreciate any opinions nonetheless.

I get:
Brett Gardner
Nick Markakis

He gets:
Andys McCutchen
LaRoche

R&R below:
12 Team H2H (pts based)
Single = 1
Double = 2
Triple = 3
Home Run = 4
Run = 1
RBI = 1
Walk = 1
Stolen Base = 2
Caught Stealing = -1

My roster
C Kurt Suzuki (C/U, OAK)
1B Miguel Cabrera (1B/U, DET)
2B Robinson Cano (2B/U, NYY)
3B David Freese (3B/U, STL)
SS Troy Tulowitzki (SS/U, COL)
Bn Andrew McCutchen (OF/U, PIT)
OF Hunter Pence (OF/U, HOU)
OF Ryan Braun (OF/U, MIL)
U Kelly Johnson (2B/U, ARI)
Pitcher
P Seattle Mariners (P, SEA)
Bench
Bn Andy LaRoche (3B/U, PIT)
Bn Aramis Ramirez (3B/U, CHC)
Bn Alexei Ramirez (SS/U, CWS)
OF Rajai Davis (OF/U, OAK)
Bn Jason Kubel (OF/U, MIN)
Injured Hitters
DL Kendry Morales (1B/U, LAA)

[boyogold]

bump for peak

[KronJon]

This is a little tricky because of the scoring system you use. Can you post the current point value of each of these players first? I know that the walk rate markakis is putting up will make him more valuable than he seems.

In the meantime, take a look at mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=413775

[boyogold]

Yeah, not a fan of the point system either, but I play what's dealt.

This year:
McCutchen - 180
LaRoche - 93


Gardner - 178
Markakis - 158

The numbers make it seem like a no brainer to me...and not just these numbers. A comparison of stats would only put me back on HRs.