does Miguel Cabrera belong in my outfield?

[Twinskies]

I almost shat myself when i saw this guy went undrafted, i wanna pick him up but i already have a tight roster as it is. My outfielders are Carlos Beltran, Carlos Lee, and Jose Guillen with Carl Crawford as my utility man. Do u think i should replace Guillen and his 30+ hrs and .300 avg with Miguel Cabrera and his huge upside?

[Mighty Monks]

Replacing GUillen might not be a bad idea, but couldnt you drop a bench player instead and keep both?

[pibb55]

Or you could use him as your 3bman, either way he should definetely be on your team unless your in a 4 player league

[biju]

Do u think i should replace Guillen and his 30+ hrs and .300 avg with Miguel Cabrera and his huge upside?

Who do you have at 3B? Doesn't Cabrera qualify at 3rd in your league? I'm in the same boat where I don't want to drop any outfielders but I'm more than happy to pick him up to replace my 3B hole.

[bost0n]

I'd rather have cabrera than guillen, but as everyone else said: who is your 3bman and who is on your bench? Im sure you have a bench player that isnt as good as cabrera. If you put him on the bench you can always rotate him in at 3b and OF, which is probably better than whoever you have on your bench that plays one position.

[jbuk]

Another vote for Cabrera over Guillen

[KolbSaves]

I'd rather have Guillen so call me crazy.

[HollywoodHershiserz]

people keep expecting Guillen to bust, but I'll tell ya, after what he did last year and what I see so far this Spring, something tells me the season won't be any different.

[jbones733]

i personally dont like Guillen, but think hes going to do ok in Seattle, just a feeling maybe 25-30 - 100

I also think Cabrera is capable of the same

[Pedantic]

i personally dont like Guillen, but think hes going to do ok in Seattle, just a feeling maybe 25-30 - 100

I also think Cabrera is capable of the same

Seattle?