deal Utley and co. for Ubaldo and Rollins? WHIR

[CubsFan4Life23]

You know I am going to go against everyone on this one. The reason being, is that no matter how good UJ is as a pitcher, he is also due to come back down to reality, as Lincecum has and Grienke etc. Not that he isnt a top 5 or 10 SP, Coors is just rough to pitch at once the weather gets hotter, balls will take off more. Utley to me, is the best player in the deal. Rollins, Lidge are both DL issues and Wigs, well "he can't keep it up." I think you do your best to shop someone like Kinsler before you shop Utley. Kinsler/Soria for UJ/Lidge, would be a much better all around deal, or something similar.

help me if you can

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=413667

[jaybball23]

I dont think theres much left to say on this topic, but I would definitely do that trade if your still considering. Ubaldo will cool down a little but he's still going to be great and rollins if he can stay healthy will be much better than alviles. Although Kinsler is not as good as Utley, he is good and worth the downgrade for the upgrade you are getting at other positions.

[krunchyfrogg]

I think this a good deal. I would hang on to aviles until Rollins has proven himself to be healthy. Since it is a H2H league I would probably drop Peavy.

I agree with this guy completely.

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=413670