analyze this trade

[miracles716]

i give up

crawford
jose batista
foukodome
garland


i get back

ellsbury
big panda
pagan
and f. cordero

any help would be appreciated

my team

Nick Hundley
(SD - C) CUtilBN NYM 7:05 pm 1% -/- - - - - -
C Yadier Molina
(StL - C) CUtilBN Cin 5:15 pm 55% -/- - - - - -
1B Prince Fielder
(Mil - 1B) 1BCIUtilBN @Fla 4:10 pm 93% -/- - - - - -
2B Orlando Hudson
(Min - 2B) 2BMIUtilBN @Sea 7:10 pm 29% -/- - - - - -
3B José Bautista
(Tor - 3B,OF) 3BCIOFUtilBN TB 4:07 pm 76% -/- - - - - -
SS Álex González
(Tor - SS) SSMIUtilBN TB 4:07 pm 69% -/- - - - - -
CI Miguel Tejada
(Bal - 3B,SS) 3BSSCIMIUtilBN @NYY 4:05 pm 45% -/- - - - - -
MI Starlin Castro
(ChC - SS) SSMIUtilBN ^ @Pit 4:05 pm 29% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
OF Jayson Werth
(Phi - OF) OFUtilBN ^ @Atl 4:10 pm 86% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
OF Carl Crawford
(TB - OF) OFUtilBN @Tor 4:07 pm 96% -/- - - - - -
OF Will Venable
(SD - OF) OFUtilBN NYM 7:05 pm 5% -/- - - - - -
OF Mike Cameron
(Bos - OF) OFUtilBN x Oak 4:10 pm 3% -/- - - - - -
OF Kosuke Fukudome
(ChC - OF) OFUtilBN ^ @Pit 4:05 pm 21% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
Util Adrián Béltre
(Bos - 3B) 3BCIUtilBN ^ Oak 4:10 pm 59% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
BN Dustin Pedroia
(Bos - 2B) 2BMIUtilBN ^ Oak 4:10 pm 87% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
BN Yunel Escobar
(Atl - SS) SSMIUtilBN ^ Phi 4:10 pm 29% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
BN --empty-- - - - - - - -
DL --empty-- - - - - - - -
DL Carlos Beltrán
(NYM - OF) DL OFUtilBNDL @SD 7:05 pm 2% -/- - - - - -
Starting Lineup Totals - 0 0 0 0 -
Trends Pitching
Pos Edit Pitchers Edit Opp Status % Started IP W SV K ERA WHIP
P Barry Zito
(SF - P) PBN ^ Col 7:15 pm 77% - - - - - -
P Dallas Braden
(Oak - P) PBN @Bos 4:10 pm 38% - - - - - -
P Jeremy Guthrie
(Bal - P) PBN @NYY 4:05 pm 2% - - - - - -
P Ubaldo Jiménez
(Col - P) PBN @SF 7:15 pm 86% - - - - - -
P Jon Garland
(SD - P) PBN NYM 7:05 pm 35% - - - - - -
P Carlos Silva
(ChC - P) PBN @Pit 4:05 pm 22% - - - - - -
P Derek Lowe
(Atl - P) PBN Phi 4:10 pm 32% - - - - - -
P Jhoulys Chacin
(Col - P) PBN @SF 7:15 pm 9% - - - - - -
P Kerry Wood
(Cle - P) PBN @Det 4:05 pm 23% - - - - - -
BN Brett Myers
(Hou - P) PBN ^ Was 5:05 pm 9% - - - - - -
BN Javier Vázquez
(NYY - P)

[hwzdavu]

Is it just me or is this crazy? I wouldn't give up Crawford for any one or all of those guys. Then throw in Bautista who has 16 homers this year??? Ellsbury is back on the DL and who knows if he'll be healthy again this year.

Do not do it!!!

[miracles716]

i made the offer before ellsbury got hurt again, but i thought i was selling high on jose and garland who i cant possibly image keeping it up all season, so panda>>jose, cordero>>>garland, and pagan>koske and ellsbury healty is better than carl, anyone else agree?

[LMack]

A healthy Ellsbury is not better than a healthy Crawford, but I'd do it.

[miracles716]

Does anyone else agree?