Hanley / Longoria trade

[rails80]

Opened up my email to see this offer:

I send: Evan Longoria, Brian Wilson
I receive: Hanley Ramirez, Colby Lewis, Troy Glaus

My instinct is NO. Any thoughts?

I should also say that I picked up Brignac when Bartlett got hurt. Guys like O-Cab and Alexei are available still...

10x10 H2H league counting: R, HR, RBI, TB, K, RC, SBN, GIDP, AVG, OPS and HR, K, QS, W, SV, ERA, OBA, WHIP, K/9, K/BB

C - VMart, Martin
1B - Fielder
2B - Zobrist
3B - Longoria
SS - Brignac
MI - Prado
CI - Cuddyer
OF - McCutchen, Soriano, R Davis, Willingham, Podsednik
Util - G Jones, Lind
BN - Bartlett
DL - Ellsbury

SP - J Johnson, Lilly, Zito, Romero
RP - Bell, Wilson, Corpas,
P - Marmol, C Perez, Slowey
BN - Beckett, Anderson, Cecil
DL - De La Rosa

[RyeWhiskey]

I would not make that trade. My first instinct was to side with Longoria/Wilson and say do it, but then I re-read and saw that you'd be losing those two. No, I'd stay put on this one.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=413584

[Darth Danielus]

Yikes. Not so cut n dry to me. Hanley and longoria are both savages, to be sure - but I'd rather have hanley at SS. That said, I'm not sure whatever value-gap between them is enough to warrent losing a decent closer. I'd certainly think long and hard on this one -- probably easier the fill 3B with decent production then getting much use out of the brignacs of the world.

[LMack]

TB and OPS probably tip it a little more Longoria's way. I'd stay put here.
In a standard 5x5 I'd probably take Hanley side though.