Jeter/Hanley and Pitchers Swap *WHIR*

[SparhawkJC01]

This trade was proposed to me and I'm thinking about taking it. 10 team h2h, standard yahoo 5x5 scoring.

I give:
Derek Jeter
David Price
Cliff Lee

I Get:
Hanley Ramirez
Dan Haren
Tim Hudson

My full team is :

C: Matt Wieters
1b: Joey Votto
2b: Ty Wiggington
3b: Jose Bautista
MI: Billy Butler
OF: Ryan Braun
OF: Chris Young
OF: Jay Bruce
OF: Adam Lind
Util: Stephen Drew
Bench: Paul Konerko
Bench: Jacoby Ellsbury *DL*
Bench: Austin Jackson
DL: Brian Roberts

SP: David Price
SP: Phil Hughes
SP: Francisco Liriano
RP: Brian Wilson
RP: Jose Valverde
P: Kevin Gregg
P: Cliff Lee
P: A.J. Burnett
Bench: Josh Beckett*DL*
Bench: Ervin Santana

Any input is appreciated, and will always help in your thread if requested.

[mshimmyb]

I think Price is just pitching way too well right now and is on such a good team to give him up... If he's the deciding factor to pick up Hanley i might do it but i would try to take off Price and make it a two for two trade.... check out my post in this forum and help me decide which SS to pick up...

[SammyRulz]

i love this deal for you..hanley over jeter..and I like haren to turn things around...you win by most all accounts

jump on it.
thanx for the help with mine

[Bjorne Greece]

I wouldn't do it with Price AND Lee. Hanley is fantastic but Jeter is very consistent and puts up top tier SS #'s every season. Mainly though I don't like that of the 4 pitchers in this deal you're giving up the 2 best. Haren always does poorly in the 2nd half - what if he has this kind of first half and then his typical 2nd half as well? Uh oh.

[Guido_BagDonnavich]

I don't think I would do it. I think that Price is the real deal and Lee is a proven top 10 guy. Haren is always worse the 2nd half of the year and this year he is already bad in May. I also expect Hudson to regress a little bit. Hanley is great, but Jeter is always very solid.

[SparhawkJC01]

Thanks for the responses so far guys. Here is the other manager's team. Do you think I can ask him to include another one of his pitchers in the deal instead of Hudson? The main reason he wants to deal is to get rid of Haren so I think I would be stuck with him either way.

C: Kurt Suzuki
1b: Adrian Gonzales
2b: Martin Prado
3b: Ian Stewart
SS: Hanley Ramirez
IF: Carlos Pena
OF: Werth, Gardner, CarGo, Granderson
UTIL: David Ortiz
Bench: Placido Polanco

SP: Tommy Hanson, Dan Haren, Josh Johnson
RP: Marmol, Cordero
P: Aardasma, Dotel, Clayton Kershaw
Bench: Tim Hudson, Johnathan Sanchez, Jaime Garcia, Brett Anderson

[waltb87]

Thanks for your help with mine...and I love the deal, you don't have anyone that you are giving up really for getting one of the best players in the league and Haren is still a solid starter will give you more help than Lee will, just has no run support and Tim Hudson can get you wins, won't be a high strikeout guy but good nonetheless...i would definitely do it

[SparhawkJC01]

Completed the deal and ended up getting the other owner to include Hanson instead of Hudson so the final transaction was:

I give:
Derek Jeter
David Price
Cliff Lee

I get:
Hanley Ramirez
Dan Haren
Tommy Hanson

[teaaker]

Didn't like it at all, too much pitching to give up. Now with hanson, I think this is going to be a good trade. However, I think that this is the type of trade that would be best in keeper leagues

viewtopic.php?t=413423

[waltb87]

now i think you got a steal, especially if you got Hanson..