Carlos Santana or Miguel Montero? WHIR

[shoelessjoetara]

I am in a 14 team mixed roto league and currently have Weiters as my starting catcher but so far I am not impressed. Who would be the better stash player Santana or Montero. Santana is going to be called up soon but will likely go through bumps here and there but has great potential. Montero has experience and had a great season last year and will come off the DL soon. I am leaning towards Montero but would like to get others opinions.

[Johnny Tuttle]

If you have an open DL slot, take the both now.

But it's Montero for me.

Weiters should be your cautionary tale for rookie/young C, no? Even Montero's later blooming supports the notion that C take a bit to hit.

And now for the possibly hypocritical
viewtopic.php?t=413359