Do either one of these trades help my team?

[abrage22]

5x5 H2H Redraft league:

Im currently in last place, the main reason seems to be my pitching giving me a horrible ERA and WHIP every week. So heres two offers, are either of them worth doing?
#1- I give McGehee, Wainwright and Kennedy
I get Lester, Marcum and Billingsly

#2- I give McGehee
I get Billingsly

MY ROSTER:
C- McCann
1- Butler
2- Cano
SS- Tulowitzki
3- Zimmerman
CI- McGehee
MI- M. Prado
OF-Adam Jones
OF- Braun
OF- Bruce
OF- BJ Upton
DH- Guerrero

SP- Wainwright
SP- Hamels
SP- Nolasco
SP- Hanson
SP- Ian Kennedy
RP- Soria
RP- Feliz

B- Wieters
B- Dice-K
B- Happ
B- JD Drew
B- Ad.Laroche
B- Chris B Young
B- John Garland

[baegames]

I assume you are using your bench pitchers every week. If so, I would go get Billingsley for McGehee, and start LaRoche.

Help with mine:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xU0BebHh5LY

[fameb]

I like both trades, but Wainwright is the best pitcher in the deal. I don't trust Marcum after major surgery last year, and Billingsly started off bad. Lester is good but Wainright is better. I think I would go for the McGahee - Billingsly deal. It's safer and you still likely improve your pitching.

Please help
viewtopic.php?t=413343

[abrage22]

thanks, anyone else?

[h_bogan]

I would do the McGehee for Bills deal, I'm a huge fan of Wainwright.