Youk and Verlander for Grienke and Fielder

[healyja]

Which side would you rather have?

At first glance I was like No way am I trading Fielder and Grienke, but I am now actually considering it. What do you guys think

10 Team Roto League, Extra Categories are OPS and QS.
Current Points, 10 Runs, 10 Hr, 9 RBI,10 SB,7 AVG, 9 OPS,7.5 W, 3 Saves, 7 K, 9 ERA, 7.5 WHIP, 6 QS




C-Cervelli
1B-Fielder
2B- Phillips
SS-Ramirez
3B-Longoria
MI-Prado
CI-Oritz
OF-Hamilton
OF-Cruz
OF-Heyward
OF-Garnder
Util-Bourn
Util-Konerko
B-Stanton
B-Ordonez
DL-Rollins
DL-Montero

SP-Felix
SP-Grienke
RP-Wilson
RP-Wagner
P-Wood
P-Rivera
P-Corpas
P-Garcia
B-Shields
B-Garza
B-Kennedy

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i think it's a fair trade, but i'd probably stay put. Fielder just has a bigger upside than Youk, and it doesn't look like you're hurting for W which is the one cat Grienke lacks.

stay put


thanks

[HighHeater]

no way i give up fielder

[Thursday]

No way. In my opinion, downgrades at both positions for you in this deal.

Keeper league? It's an even easier no.

Help out:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=413331

[AquaMan2342]

I'd hold even though I like Verlander over Grienke because having Grienke/Felix probably won't yield you many wins.

[Deux]

you are pretty much paying for wins with HR's+fielders upside IMO. I'd hold still if i were you

[The Artful Dodger]

I still think Fielder is the best player in the deal and with Verlander and Greinke being on the same top tier, you should keep the Fielder side.