Pick one: 2010 Catcher, Posey or Santana.

[Peloquin]

Santana. He seems to be 1000% ready.
Posey won't play. Huff and Molina are too proven-veterany™ .

BTW LOL@ the Dodgers for trading away Santana. They're lucky Blake has kept up a decent standard of production.

Huff will most likely move to to the outfield with Posey at first. Won't be long before he gains 1B eligibility.

[Thursday]

Grabbed Posey b/c of the 1st base thing - if he's getting regular starts, he becomes invaluable at the C position.

[wrveres]

okay i changed my mind, i went with Posey. That first base thing is too much to pass up.

[RedHopeful]

Honestly what's up with the first base eligibility being so invaluable? Their current permanent positions are at C -- that's what matters a good hitter eligible at the catcher position.

Santana gets the nod because he already possess the ability to knock it out of the park more easily.

[clevername]

the odds of Posey being valuable as a catcher are probably much higher than his odds of being valuable as a first basemen given supply. I don't see how the first base eligibility really makes a difference other than assuring owners that Posey should get at bats since he can play at either position. As pointed out, though, once Santana is up he should be playing so I don't think it makes a difference.

As for which one, who knows. I like Posey, but I like Santana's potential fantasy value more since he appears to have more power.

[NotAmused]

I like Santana more (more power and Posey is hitting in an extreme pitchers park)

I just picked up Posey though, hopefully he can do more for me than K Suzuki was.

[wrveres]

Honestly what's up with the first base eligibility being so invaluable?

its not the elig. that matters, its the everyday ab's from the catcher position

[shmolex]

I like Santana more (more power and Posey is hitting in an extreme pitchers park)

I just picked up Posey though, hopefully he can do more for me than K Suzuki was.

AT&T park isn't the extreme pitchers park it used to be. It's actually about average now.