Schmidt,Brown or Beckett??

[Daman]

Who would you take and why??

[Area51's]

Schmidt
then
Beckett
then
Brown


You could probably talk me into Beckett over Schmidt, because of arm falling-off-ness, but none of the three guys are green on the injury scale. Just think between weighing talent, and injury potential, that is how I'd group the three.

Would love to have any of them, but all of them would make me pretty nervous all season long, w/ Beckett making me the least nervous

[Cornbread Maxwell]

Great question.

I would draft them in the order you mentioned: Schmidt, Brown, Beckett.

HOWEVER - I like Brown to have the best yr, followed by Schmidt and Beckett.

[kentx12]

Schmidt starting on the DL scares me. I would go with Brown, Beckett then Schmidt. I believe he will be fine but would not take a chance on him as high as he will go in the draft.

[Freebird27]

Schmidt starting on the DL scares me. I would go with Brown, Beckett then Schmidt. I believe he will be fine but would not take a chance on him as high as he will go in the draft.

Diddo on Schmidt, Brown and beckett are really close IMO..with the edge going to Brown in pinstripes

[Dude86]

I like Beckett over both of them. He is healthy,young, and ready for a breakout season.

[Absolutely Adequate]

I like Beckett the most out of that group, though I think that he'll be drafted the latest out of the list.


And it's "ditto."

[Chip]

wanna know something funny?

I've got all 3.