3 big keeper Trades WHIR 100%

[Alexs]

there's 3 options 2 questions- which is best option and am i wrong to take any of them??

option 1- I Give rollins/choo and my 3rd
I get Soriano/Prince

I feel like i'm giving up too much...thoughts?

option 2- I Give rollins/webb/e jackson my 1st 4th 10th
I get M Cab, Andrus, Bills

option 3- I give rollins webb e jackson and a 5th
I get reynolds/andrus/bills

c-Doumit
1b-D Lee
2b-mcgahee
3b-zimmerman
ss-Rollins/theriot
OF-justin upton, choo, mccutchen, damon, (sizemore on DL)
RP villanueva papelbon feliz
SP gallardo dempster matusz maholm a sanchez e jackson (brett anderson and webb on DL)

12 team keeper league h2h 5x5 with h, bb, tb, ops and L, CG, SHO, QS

keep 4 players each year

[mhuhn23]

Do the 1st, 4th, 10th, etc. mean that rounds pick in next years draft?

Even so, I like option B. You get Cabrera, and sure losing those picks hurts but he is a top 5 player in my opinion. Not to mention I think Andrus will be a stud and is a good replacement for Rollins. And you get rid of Webb and Jackson for Billingsley which will help.

It looks like he is building for next year, and in that case I like this deal as he is giving you a lot, and a top keeper option at that.

[Alexs]

ya the picks at the end are the picks for nexts years draft, but the 1st is really like a 5th or so since the first four rounds are your keepers

[sigriffey]

Option 2 is awesome IMO -- Rollins is an injury headache as is Webb; Jackson is inconsistent. YOu get a high upside SS in Andrus, a stud in MCab, and a guy who looks to have turned it around and gets loads of K's in Bills.

[snowboa1712]

i agree with the above option 2 is the way to go

[soty]

#2 is the way to go.

[CubsFan4Life23]

We're all in agreement...Cabrera is a stud and only 26...that's a good 6 years of solid production you'll get in return.

help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=413054

[tgt2e]

I definitely have to go with the consensus here. Option 2 is a really good deal IMO. You do lose some top picks BUT you're picking up Miggy and Andrus for very little.