how'd I do?? WHIR

[Alexs]

My old team is below

The trade I give Votto, Guillen, and granderson

I get Mccutchen, D Lee, and Gallardo

c-Doumit
1b-Votto
2b-mcgahee
3b-zimmerman
ss-Rollins/theriot
OF-justin upton, choo, guillen, damon, (sizemore, granderson on DL)
RP villanueva papelbon feliz
SP dempster matusz maholm a sanchez e jackson (brett anderson and webb on DL)

12 team keeper league h2h 5x5 with h, bb, tb, ops and L, CG, SHO, QS

keep 4 players each year

[krunchyfrogg]

thanks for help with mine.


Lee > Votto
McCutchen >= Granderson
Gallardo > Guillen

I like your side more, as the step down from Votto to Lee is easily surpassed by gallardo's strikeouts. Guillen is not the real deal. McCutchen and Granderson are close, but I think McCutchen is a better player, but Granderson will earn more Runs and RBI in that ballpark and lineup.

[Alexs]

any other responses?

[VikingGuy84]

Thanks for helping with mine. I think you lose on the Votto vs. Lee part of the trade. But I think you win on the McCutchen/Gallardo vs. Guillen/Granderson part. Hopefully Lee can pick up his stats for you too. I really like McCutchen though...

[Bjorne Greece]

You did come out better on that. You do have to give up something to get something so it's understandable that you had to give Votto but you at least got Lee in return. He's always consistent. Guillen will do what Guillen always does - nothing special. Gallardo is a good pickup. I love McCutchen. I've been trying to get him from his owner all year long in my league.

[Darth Danielus]

I'd say pretty close.....I prefer votto over lee aswell...


help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=413059

[mac-unit]

I like McCutchen over Granderson. Votto over Lee and I'd rather have Gallardo over Guillen, even more since you won't need the OF help.