Im in a 12 Team H2H with the following cats scored. I was offered Peavy for Podsednik
AVG, R, HR, RBI, SBI, OPS, E, KO ERA, WHIP, HRA, W, SV, K, K/BB
Here is my roster
C Russell Martin 1B Miguel Cabrera 2B Ian Kinsler 3B Edwin Encarnacion SS Hanley Ramirez OF Jacoby Ellsbury OF Andrew McCutchen OF Jason Heyward OF Johnny Damon UTIL Howie Kendrick BN Juan Pierre BN Scott Podsednik BN Troy Glaus
SP Tim Lincecum SP Josh Beckett SP Tommy Hanson SP Derek Holland SP Clay Buchholz SP Edwin Jackson SP Ian Kennedy SP Gio Gonzalez RP Brian Fuentes RP Joakim Soria RP Kevin Gregg
I think this would be a decent offer for me since I am deep at OF, have a lot of speed, etc. Peavy makes me nervous but I think he'd be an upgrade at SP for me
What do you think? Ill help in return just leave a link!
no doubt--peavy's iffy thus far, but has borderline top-25 pitcher potential. podsednik is past his prime, liable to not hit as well as he is all season, and is a 3-cat player at best. additionally, you have juan pierre and podsednik on your bench, even though both are virtually the same in terms of what they add-i think theres no question this is a good deal, you essentially lose nothing because you dont need two speedy, run-producing OFs on your bench. peavy's ADP was around 100 (maybe has dropped slightly in value, but id take him for sure), podsednik's well above 200 so value-wise its a good deal too. id do it without a second thought.
c-olivo 1b-d lee/smoak 2b-mcgahee 3b-zimmerman ss-Rollins/theriot OF-upton, choo, mccutchen, damon, (sizemore on DL) RP villanueva papelbon feliz SP gallardo, dempster matusz maholm bailey e jackson (brett anderson and webb on DL)