Would you do this trade?

[ECG77]

Not a very big trade but I would like to get thoughts.

Tony K. Gwynn and Carlos Villanueva
for
Mark DeRosa (Injury prone)

NL Only
5X5 Rotisserie
10 Teams
FA Dollars are allowed in trades

My roster as of now:

Active
Geovany Soto C
Yorvit Torrealba C
Albert Pujols 1B
Dan Uggla 2B
Scott Rolen 3B
Ian Desmond SS
Everth Carbrera MI
Adrian Gonzalez CI
Mark DeRosa OF (DL)
Jonny Gomes OF
Carlos Gomez OF
Cody RossOF
Micheal Stanton OF
Ronny Cedeno U

Jhoulys Chacin SP
Tyler Clippard RP
Aaron Cook SP
Johnny Cueto SP
Jon Garland SP
Jason Hammel SP
Livan Hernandez SP
Adama Wainwright SP
Randy Wolf SP

Reserves
Mat Gamel (DL)
Arodlis Chapman SP
Jorge De La Rosa SP
Huston Street RP (DL)

[Goatrider]

what's up man,

If you got an open roster spot, then check out Luis Durango. Speedster for SD just called up. I just picked him up and happen to be in a trade negotiation with gwynn on the dude's team. We are looking for gwynn as a throw in now becuase no matter what happens with those two, you got SD lead off hitter and steals (which is no little thing in NL only). I'd do the trade. Villanueva will bridge your time until Street comes back in June. So even if Hoff comes back, stick him in reserves for awhile and then cut him if won't be the closer. You won't lose much. DeRosa will be a bum for the rest of the year and he's 36 or 37. According to Giants website, he's going to get another opinion and then rehab. On top of that, Posey has to get the call some time and that will push Huff to LF (which he coincedentially played for the first time this year tonight) Make the deal.

[ECG77]

Oh i already have plans to pick up Durango. I do believe DeRosa is done.

Thanks, man.

[ECG77]

Should I pick up Zach Braddock also?

[Goatrider]

If you got the room, I'd do it. Braddock is taken in my league, so I re-picked coffey just in case Villanueva's situation gets rocky (becuase it probably will). Wish I was hedging my bets w/ Braddock. I wouldn't drop anyone to do it though.

[Goatrider]

hey,
we got a guy who put Lincecum, Wainwright, Haren on the block. Take a look and tell me what you think.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=412884