Mccutchen/votto keeper trade, 100% WHIR

[NWilli]

Well, I had Votto and Lee ranked about the same at the beginning of the season, but Votto is clearly outperforming him thus far, so you're probably coming out behind if this were the only part of the trade. Gallardo is not worth a second rounder. However, Holliday/McCutchen over Granderson is a big upgrade.

The question is, is upgrading your OF worth a downgrade at 1B and giving up a 2nd rounder for a mid-round pitcher? I'm not really sure, and this feels like a double-edged trade. If you really like McCutchen you can go for it, because he can help your team for a long time. I might just stick with your current team though.

Thanks for the help by the way.

[Jenken]

I too would go Cutch over Holliday. Losing Votto stings but the return is well worth it.

Thanks for the help