McCutchen for Dunn?

[Larry Doby Johnson]

I was just offered Andrew McCutchen for my Adam Dunn. It's a 10 team 6x6 Roto league (OPS added).
I've got a 10 in runs, 8 in HR, 8 in RBI, and 8 in OPS, with a 6 in AVG so offense has been very good. However, with a 4.5 in SB, I'd love to have McCutchen.
On paper, trading away HR which I'm doing fine in for SB which I need makes sense. But I'm still hesitant because of Dunn's consistency.
Should I pull the trigger on this?

6x6 Roto (OPS and Quality Starts added)

C- F. Cervelli
1B- A. Pujols
2B- P. Polanco
3B- K. Youklis
SS- J. Reyes
CI- J. Morneau
MI- J. Bartlett
OF- M. Holliday
OF- S. Podsednik
OF- A. Dunn
OF- D. Span
Util- B. Hawpe
Util- J. Cantu
BN- K. Fukudome
BN- Carlos Lee
DL- M. Montero

SP- M. Cain
SP- T. Hanson
SP- R. Oswalt
SP- T. Hudson
SP- J. Niemann
SP- S. Marcum
SP. C. Lewis
SP. J. Chacin
RP- F. Rodriguez
RP- F. Cordero
RP- J. Valverde
RP- M. Lindstom
RP- M. Lindstrom

[bigdawg78]

if this is a keeper league, it is a deffinate yes.. as mccutch will be good for years (IMO)..

if its a redraft its a smaller yes, (but still a yes).. McCutch has the skill-set of a Crawford (IMO) decent avg, some power, and speed..

so IMO yes (but i also love mccutchen)

[fast dogs]

another biased vote for McCutchen

[Goatrider]

I own Dunn and have top spot in HR, R, RBI's, Mid in AVG, and bottom of pack in SB. I'd jump at it. And if it's a keeper league, big yes. I have a mancrush on McCutchen though. He's got pop too and bats 3rd.

help if ya would
viewtopic.php?t=412884