Aaron Hill or Kelly Johnson?

[Favin]

I have K. Johnson and have been offered Aaron Hill straight up for him. Whats best for overall value from today through end of this season in 5x5 roto?

[Jenken]

Hill, no question.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=412829

[DKuon]

this has to be a joke. Right?

Johnson:

* Avg .257
* HR 12
* RBI 25
* Runs 31
* SB 3

Hill:
* Avg .161
* HR 5
* RBI 13
* Runs 19
* SB 1

[Favin]

nope....Aaron Hill for Kelly Johnson straight up...you say keep Johnson??

[moflo19]

It's been almost 2 months now and Aaron Hill has shown no sign of breaking out. I traded Hill for Grady Sizemore last week. Kelly Johnson for me.

[Favin]

But.....last year....

Johnson:
* Avg .224
* HR 8
* RBI 229
* Runs 47
* SB 7

Hill:
* Avg .286
* HR 36
* RBI 108
* Runs 103
* SB 3

I do not think it is that clear....the case can be made for Hill here....

[bigdawg78]

IMO both are mediocre at best.. (although Hill had a great year last year)...

Johnson is going to fall to earth yet... (IMO)..

but i'd still go with Johnson.. just my thoughts though

[baegames]

My first inclination was, duh, Aaron Hill. And then I thought - one had a bad year last year, the other one so far this year.

Hill: 263/324/361
Johnson: 287/349/446

Yes, we can look at last year. Two years ago, the above was the splits. Johnson has more of a track record. Go with Johnson.

viewtopic.php?t=412863