what are the thoughts on Alfonso Soriano?

[lastingsgriller]

do we think he is just hot and a good sell high candidate..

or is it a possibility that he's knees were just plaguing him last year and the surgery has done wonders to bring his game back. It wasn't long ago that he was an elite force in this game and he's been pretty dang good so far this year. could he possibly be a great player still that is not a sell high candidate, but insted, keep and watch him dominate the whole season??

[DaSh 1s]

do we think he is just hot and a good sell high candidate..

or is it a possibility that he's knees were just plaguing him last year and the surgery has done wonders to bring his game back. It wasn't long ago that he was an elite force in this game and he's been pretty dang good so far this year. could he possibly be a great player still that is not a sell high candidate, but insted, keep and watch him dominate the whole season??

I am holding. No one is convinced Soriano is back, so his current hot streak is much more fun than anything you could realistically expect back in a trade.

[Dan Lambskin]

these thoughts are only a few weeks old...should still be relevent

[mkultra]

Sell. For the past few seasons, Soriano would have a few weeks early where he'll singlehandedly carry your team, then do nothing for weeks on end. Consistency is not his thing.

[thebawler]

I'm thinking keep 'em, hes playing extremely well and I heard he has been doing all the right things work ethic-wise.

I have him on my team and I was a little annoyed how he kept getting days off even though producing offensively at a very high rate, but they are now moving him to cleanup I think he'll be more of an everyday player now and I believe the hitting ability is fully there again, but just not the speed like he used to have.

[thatguy27]

do we think he is just hot and a good sell high candidate..

or is it a possibility that he's knees were just plaguing him last year and the surgery has done wonders to bring his game back. It wasn't long ago that he was an elite force in this game and he's been pretty dang good so far this year. could he possibly be a great player still that is not a sell high candidate, but insted, keep and watch him dominate the whole season??

I am holding. No one is convinced Soriano is back, so his current hot streak is much more fun than anything you could realistically expect back in a trade.

This is my take as well. You probably won't get a whole lot in return if you look to trade him, so just ride it out. I suppose it's worth it to let your league mates know he's available and see what kind of offers you get, but I doubt they'll be to your liking.

[StlSluggers]

In a H2H league, I'd sell if you can get any good value for him.

He's a head case, and you'll be one, too, if you rely on him in anything other than a roto league.

[urbanbreez]

In a H2H league, I'd sell if you can get any good value for him.

He's a head case, and you'll be one, too, if you rely on him in anything other than a roto league.

Roto League? He's streaky. Predictably streaky. I think he's perfect for H2H with this HRs in bunches he can carry your team for a week. If you play in a daily league, even better. Pull him when he's cold and wait for the next 3/4. He's a perfect OF3 and so far, an excellent value for his draft position.

[StlSluggers]

In a H2H league, I'd sell if you can get any good value for him.

He's a head case, and you'll be one, too, if you rely on him in anything other than a roto league.

Roto League? He's streaky. Predictably streaky. I think he's perfect for H2H with this HRs in bunches he can carry your team for a week. If you play in a daily league, even better. Pull him when he's cold and wait for the next 3/4. He's a perfect OF3 and so far, an excellent value for his draft position.

I prefer the opposite approach. You can make a good bet on the streaks balancing out in roto.

In H2H, he can cost you weeks. Sure, he can win you them, too, but I prefer not to expose myself to the downside risk.