Gallardo/Manny for Weeks/Ibanez/Nunez??

[Cobra_Kai]

Need some help evaluating a trade offer I've been sent.

NL-only league, HR R RBI SB OBP/ K ERA WHIP SV QS

I give: Rickie Weeks, Raul Ibanez, Leo Nunez
I get: Yovani Gallardo, Manny Ramirez, Luis Castillo

Castillo is garbage, so clearly I'd just drop him after the deal anyway. I've got Prado to slide in at 2B.

Manny is clearly an upgrade from Ibanez, and I need the pitching help. The question is, am I giving up too much? Nunez has been great, but I don't think his numbers are sustainable (and neither does Fangraphs). Weeks hasn't been great since early in the season.

My roster:

C: R. Doumit
1B: A. Pujols
2B: R. Weeks
3B: J. Cantu/ M. Prado
SS: S. Drew
IF: A. Gonzalez (SDG)
LF: R. Ibanez
CF: S. Victorino
RF: J. Upton
OF: D. Stubbs/ C. Gomez/ K. Blanks
Util: J. Reyes

SP: D. Haren
SP: T. Lilly
SP: E. Jackson
SP: M. Pelfrey
RP: L. Nunez
RP: J. Contreras
RP: M. Corpas
RP: S. Marshall
P: W. LeBlanc
BN: J. Chacin
DL: J. Jurrjens

Really thinking about pulling the trigger here, but I'd love to get some opinions. Thanks.

[DaveClay12]

He!! to the YES!!! Weeks is eh, and Nunez is gonna come back down to earth. Manny is losing power, but he'll get his RBIs, and Gallardo, while having a high WHIP, is a fantasy stud otherwise. Yack that trade.


If you get a chance: http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=412805