Matt Kemp Trade WHIR

[Hammers]

Hey Everyone,

Someone in my keeper league wants Matt Kemp. My leagues is AL/NL mixed with 12 teams and yearly keepers (salary based keeper system). It is not head to head, you get points for everything your players do and the team with the most points wins at the end of the season.

Cuddyer isn't doing much and I would think that Upton and Bruce would produce more points than Kemp and Cuddyer. Kemp will cost more for next year's keepers than Bruce and more than Upton.

Here is the offer:

I send: Matt Kemp
I get: Jay Bruce and B.J. Upton

What do you think?

Current Team
Active Hitters
C Olivo, Miguel C COL
C Rodriguez, Ivan C WAS
1B Gonzalez, Adrian 1B SD
2B Hudson, Orlando 2B MIN
3B Youkilis, Kevin 1B BOS
SS Aybar, Eric SS ANA
OF Cuddyer, Michael RF MIN
OF Gardner, Brett CF NYY
OF Kemp, Matt CF LA
U Konerko, Paul 1B CHW
U Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA

Active Pitchers
SP Cain, Matt SP SF
SP Haren, Dan SP ARI
SP Pettitte, Andy SP NYY
SP Sanchez, Jonathan O. SP SF
SP Shields, James SP TB
RP Lindstrom, Matt RP HOU
RP Marmol, Carlos RP CHC

Bench
C Santana, Carlos C CLE
SS Furcal, Rafael SS LA
OF Jennings, Desmond CF TB
OF Young, Chris B. CF ARI
SP Bailey, Homer SP CIN
SP Tillman, Chris SP BAL
RP Rodney, Fernando RP ANA

Disabled List
2B Roberts, Brian 2B BAL
SP De La Rosa, Jorge SP COL

[Kimbos Beard]

Unless the keeper/points system is really complicated I don't think is anyway you do this deal.

You are not even getting close to the value back you should be getting for Kemp in a keeper.

[Hammers]

Yeah, that is exactly what I thought. Thank you for confirming it.

[fdny92]

I am new to fantasy world..... not the game. I don't know much how all the different leagues operate... I belong to the CBS league...week to week line up and it's a point league.... I believe.

But with all that said... I would keep Kemp.