Give Phillips + for Holliday +...? WHIR

[CubsFan4Life23]

My league is 12 teams H2H (5x5; OBP replaces AVG) we keep 3 players per year. (basic positions with 2 utility spots and 2 DL spots)

I give: B Phillips/S Drew/ J Damon I get: M Holliday/M Young... be sure to leave a link.

Catcher - K. Susuki
1B - M Cabrera, Billy Butler
2B - B Phillips, R Theriot
3B - I Stewart
SS - T Tulowitzki, S Drew
OF - J Upton, H Pence, J Damon, J Bruce

SP - Z Greinke, J Lester, T Hanson, J Garcia, J Sanchez, F Liriano
RP - J Broxton, K Wood
DL - E Bedard, B Webb, B Anderson

[CubsFan4Life23]

HELP!! Thanks

[fierro33]

id do this....phillips isnt all that good anymore....drew is blah....damon is doin great but holliday is the real prize here

[jmlevy]

You aren't keeping Phillips anyway, and Holliday is a legitimate keeper option. I say you pull the trigger.

[dubstar]

I agree to do it, but it's not a complete no brainer. Holliday is the best player of the bunch, but Drew and Phillips are solid options at those positions.

[figurski24]

I would take it because Drew and Phillips can be replaced and on the upside you get Holliday for the long run. Only thing you lose in this trade is Damon.

HELP
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=412620&p=3274207#p3274207

[Hamburglar07]

Make the trade. Phillips is going downhill, and Holliday is a stud.

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=412635