Give up Votto for Oswalt, I think not. 100% WHIR as always

[HueyntheNews]

So the guy who's 6-0 in my 10man H2H league, literally knows everything about baseball, I mean like I dont know how he does it wants me to trade Votto (who is fucking raking) for Roy Oswalt (with the 'Stros who couldn't rake a pile of leaves). He tried to sell me CJ wilson for votto earlier and I said that was equivalent to calling me retarded. So now he's back with Ozzie and I still dont like the trade, but I just wanna make sure I'm not pulling the wool over my eyes on vottos worth. I think he's top 1B. However, is oswalt is traded to a contender, I'd pretty much hit this in a heartbeat. So, thoughts? Here's his roster and mine: What do you think I should be able to get for votto if I should trade with him at all? (Sidenote: do you think its safe to use Moyer against Hou and FLA in his 2 start next week?)

I will always respond to your post if you leave a link

My Roster:
Starters: C: Soto 1B: Howard 2B: Utley 3B: Reynolds SS: Elvis Andrus OF: Torii Hunter, Denard Span, Hawpe U: Votto
SP: M. Leake, C. Hamels, J. Johnson, J. Weaver, M. Garza RP: Aardsma, Franklin
Bench: No one
Bullpen: J Moyer, Zambrano, Lily, Dempster, Liriano (Dempster and Lily in the process of being traded for Ellsbury)

His roster:
Starters: C: McCann 1B Berkman 2B Cano 3B ARod SS Jeter OF Holliday Soriano Werth U Boesch

SP: Greinke, Hughes, Lee, Cj Wilson, Wells RP: Ely, Soriano
Reserves: Cruz (who is sitting on his bench!?) Oswalt, Pettitte, Shields, Strasburg

H2H 10 Team No Keepers or DL spots:
Hitting- Singles=1 HR=4 SB=2 K=-.5 BB=1 R=1 RBI=1
Pitching- BBI=-1 INN=3 K=.5 W=7 S=7 QS=3 ER=-1 HA=-1 HB=-1 L=-5

[baegames]

Nope. With Oswalt on a contender, it becames a questionable trade. But doesn't that depend on which contender.

Say, Rockies? Nope
Giants? Yes
AL teams? maybe

That is just a sample.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=412521

[Elsy]

My Roster:
Starters: C: Soto 1B: Howard 2B: Utley 3B: Reynolds SS: Elvis Andrus OF: Torii Hunter, Denard Span, Hawpe U: Votto
SP: M. Leake, C. Hamels, J. Johnson, J. Weaver, M. Garza RP: Aardsma, Franklin
Bench: No one
Bullpen: J Moyer, Zambrano, Lily, Dempster, Liriano (Dempster and Lily in the process of being traded for Ellsbury)

His roster:
Starters: C: McCann 1B Berkman 2B Cano 3B ARod SS Jeter OF Holliday Soriano Werth U Boesch

SP: Greinke, Hughes, Lee, Cj Wilson, Wells RP: Ely, Soriano
Reserves: Cruz (who is sitting on his bench!?) Oswalt, Pettitte, Shields, Strasburg

H2H 10 Team No Keepers or DL spots:
Hitting- Singles=1 HR=4 SB=2 K=-.5 BB=1 R=1 RBI=1
Pitching- BBI=-1 INN=3 K=.5 W=7 S=7 QS=3 ER=-1 HA=-1 HB=-1 L=-5

I would send back an offer of similar quality, tells him what yo uthink of his offers. Offer him Hunter, Votto for Grienke and Cruz

[Alexs]

I would send back an offer of similar quality, tells him what yo uthink of his offers. Offer him Hunter, Votto for Grienke and Cruz

i like that deal....

votto>oswalt by himself though....
and i'd start moyer vs astros and marlins....astros are just the astros and marlins are a younger team which moyer is best against

help with mine please
viewtopic.php?t=412534

[dubstar]

I wouldn't do it due to your points system. If it was a H2H cats league, then I would strongly consider it since Oswalt could help you in 3= cats.

[fdny92]

HELLZZZZ NO to that trade!

Start Moyer..... I am!

help with mine pleaz
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=412544

[LARS929]

Honestly I wouldn't trade Votto right now at all. He could easily keep stealing bases which is just a plus. That packed with his power and solid AVG make him a top 5 1b IMO. I realize not everyone will agree with that, but he is a stud. Don't trade him unless you are getting a top 5 SP

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=412501