I'm in a 12-team H2H points league where we keep 6 players, no limit to how long you can keep players.
I was offered Heyward and Posey for Strasburg and Carlos Santana. I'm 1-6 due to a high Points Against, and I'm kinda focusing on the future...especially the long-term future, hence my focus on Heyward.
BB, TB, R, RBI, SB = 1
HR = 2
Caught Stealing, K = -1
IP = 2
K = 1
BB, Hit Allowed = -1
ER, HR Allowed = -2
W, SV = 10
Shutout = 7
No Hitter, Perfect Game, Quality Start = 5
L, Blown Save = -5
OF: G. Jones
BN: Carlos Santana, B. Wallace
(should I keep him over Markakis and/or Jeter?)
SP: Nolasco, Harang, Wandy
RP: Qualls, Simon, Contreras
BN: Matusz, Kuroda, E. Santana, Villanueva
Pitchers can get really lit up in this format with -1 for H,BB and -2 for ER, so it's kind of nice to have a frontline SP. On the other hand, I have always been a bats first, pitching second type guy, and with Heyward looking like Pujols in the K/BB department, he could be huge in a league with 1 for BB and -1 for K. I would not keep Posey over Liriano/Markakis/Jeter for my last keeper; I'd use him to upgrade one of my other keepers.
Thanks in advance for your help, and make sure to post a link so I can help you out!