Jaime Garcia for Kershaw Trade!!!

[rasto21585]

In my 20 team h2h dynasty league I was just offered kershaw for my cj wilson and jaime garcia. Is this a good deal for me?

c russel martin
1b miguel cabrera
2b howie kendrick
3b chase headley
ss ryan theriot
if justin morneau
lf carlos lee
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of ryan ludwick
util fucodome
bn blake dewitt


sp jon lester
sp colby lewis
sp mike leake
sp homer bailey
rp jaime garcia
rp rafael soriano
rp c.j. wilson
rp jason motte
p ryan rowland smith
p hisanori takahashi
p jose mijares
bn geo gonzalez
bn carlos carrasco
bn dan hudson

[Tony Micelli]

Wow, that's kinda tough ... I think I like getting Kershaw a bit more. Would you have been planning on keeping CJ Wilson or Garcia at the end of the year? Obviously Kershaw would be a keeper for you, if you went through with the trade.

[rasto21585]

we keep our whole team from year to year

[Tony Micelli]

I mean, it depends ... if you're a big Kershaw fan ... then yes. He's only 22 and is battling with control and walks and overall efficiency still. Kershaw probably has the biggest 'upside' of the 3. Wilson has been awesome, but I honestly don't know enough about him to say whether he can keep this up. Garcia is a very nice prospect as well.

[rasto21585]

do you think i can afford losing the pitching depth?

[jdip5]

take kershaw, you need a bonafide stud on that squad because you already have alotta high upside rookie sps

[espnsportsfan]

I think i would take kershaw, but who would you be able to pick up as a replacement

[rasto21585]

no idea...waiver wire is pretty thin