Rank these trades: Liriano for Upton/McCutchen/Cruz

[gogogadget]

Head to Head standard 5 x 5 scoring. Consider both teams equal in all categories, there is a trade involving Team A's Fransisco Liriano for either McCutchen, Justin Upton, or Nelson Cruz. Rank these possible trades in order of appeal to team A.

McCutchen, Upton, Cruz ????

[baseball77]

JUpton
Cruz
McCutchen

I think all 3 of those players are more valuable than Liriano.

[mcd285]

Cruz
Upton
McCutch