J.Smoak or I.Davis??? WHIR

[casem2k2]

10 team, roto league: r,hr,rbi,sb,obp

Justin Smoak or Ike Davis....

Who would you rather have?

[davdav]

I like Ike. He has been better this year. However, it could go ether way.

help!

viewtopic.php?t=412006

[TBuck4401]

I like Smoak better for the long-run, as he was considered a much better hitting prospect, and who doesn't want a Ranger bat when the summer heat turns up in Texas? However, since it's a 10-team league, you could probably ride Ike Davis right now while he's hitting better than Smoak, then drop him for Smoak when he heats up. I'm assuming he'll be there in a 10-team non-keeper league.... just don't wait too long, and watch Smoak closely.

[bears2]

toss up.both future supposedly great hitters but smoak is in a hitters park so i tend to go that way.even in slumps u hit accidental hr's in texas

[k.k.]

I'd go Smoak. That Rangers lineup is a killer, when they aren't playing the Blue Jays.

[j24jags]

I'd take Smoak

viewtopic.php?t=412048

[wkpdpack]

I'd take Smoak for the long hall. I think he was a better hitting prospect by far, plays in a hitter's park, and has a better offensive team surrounding him for better stats when he does produce.

Smoak it is.

Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=412047