Hanley or Reynolds WHIR!!!!! 2hours to make my decision!

[Zain1two3]

IF you had the luxury of trading one for the other, which one would you trade for? Reynolds is off to a bit of a slow start average wise, but both players are not stealing bases anymore!! Which one would you take? Will Reynolds start stealing?

[hartmtown]

Well, it's really impossible to know without seeing your roster. But based purely on player and position, I'd certainly trade Reynolds first. Hanley will beat him in average and runs and he's far more valuable as a SS than Reynolds is at 3B. Reynolds may hit more HR and have a few RBI, but he's also going to strike out a ton and I doubt he steals too many bases this year. Ramirez will pick it up on the basepaths.

Bottom line: Hanley's the best SS and one of the best players in baseball, while Reynolds is merely a very good 3B. Easy call.

Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=411985

[CRedsLarkin11]

Reynolds is a fine fantasy player but his value is no where close to Hanley.

[Jenken]

Hanley is by far and a way a better player than Reynolds. If u have to trade 1, trade reynolds, but not hanley (unless you are totally blown away)

[davdav]

Hanley is by far the better player. It would take a lot for me to trade him away, and there IS NO WAY I WOULD in a keeper.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=412006