Sell high on Ethier....for J. Upton?

[twistedude]

Wondering if I should sell high on the #1 player in fantasy baseball right now: Andre Ethier. Would you deal him for a slumping Justin Upton in a standard 12 team mixed league?

[Hamburglar07]

NO way. Don't even think about this.

[fitz0527]

I hate Ethier and love J. Up and I would be very hesitant to make this deal. Ethier is legit and will end up putting up huge numbers this year. I don't think Upton will match him THIS year.

[Elsy]

Sell him for something higher than J. Upton

[urbanbreez]

If you do this I will come to your house and slap you in the face.

What you want to do with Ethier is HOLD ON AND ENJOY THE RIDE.

Side note: Have you watched his swing? It's a thing of beauty, so silky smooth.

[k.k.]

If you're hoping for last year's Justin Upton and you think he'll return to that form at some point this season, then go for it. I don't know if it'll happen. Ethier is a better bet from what we've seen so far this season.

[urbanbreez]

If you're hoping for last year's Justin Upton and you think he'll return to that form at some point this season, then go for it. I don't know if it'll happen. Ethier is a better bet from what we've seen so far this season.

Man, I don't even know....where to start.

last year's Upton didn't put up numbers like this year's Ethier will. That's assuming J-up turns it around this season. Meanwhile, Ethier has been mashing all year long. Do the math. There are difficult decisions in life, this isn't one of them.

[Choptoberfest]

Do not move Ethier.

Help with mine? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=411945

[k.k.]

If you're hoping for last year's Justin Upton and you think he'll return to that form at some point this season, then go for it. I don't know if it'll happen. Ethier is a better bet from what we've seen so far this season.

Man, I don't even know....where to start.

last year's Upton didn't put up numbers like this year's Ethier will. That's assuming J-up turns it around this season. Meanwhile, Ethier has been mashing all year long. Do the math. There are difficult decisions in life, this isn't one of them.

Um, read what I wrote. I did say Ethier is a better bet. If Justin Upton finds that groove he was in last year at some point this season, he's a good bet going forward too. Ethier is super right now but you can't honestly expect him to keep this pace up all year. You're predicting Ethier's numbers for a whole season, and sorry sir, you have no crystal ball anymore than I do.