David Price + for Alex Rodriguez WHIR

[baegames]

Original thought was for Longoria. People here convinced me (on this post) not to make the offer. I will if he comes back with a lesser pitcher than David Price. I ended up offering a pitcher PLUS Kendry Morales for Evan Longoria. Have not heard back. What about this offer to a different team?

Thinking of making this offer in a 6 team AL Only:

GIVE
David Price
Kendry Morales
Brandon Morrow

GET
Brian Fuentes
Alex Rodriguez
Kevin Millwood

I have a ton of excess pitching, and I need offense.

My 3b is Mark Teahen, but I have a 1b at both CR and UT, so I'd be replacing Morales with a FA (Fred Lewis?), while Rodriguez replaces Teahen.

For his team, he has a 3b as his CR, so Morales slides straight into A-Rod's slot without anything else.

Is this a fair trade? Am I giving up too much? Am I offering too little?

[baegames]

bump

[Elsy]

I see Longoria as the only improvement and overall I think you loose that trade.

[kidsilk]

I think you lose that trade as well. I wouldn't do it.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=411947

[wkpdpack]

I, too, would not do that deal. I like Longoria but giving up Price and Morales is pretty steep.


Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=411954

[baegames]

bump for adjustments to offer

[davdav]

I agree. You are getting A-rod plus two scrubs for an ace pitcher and a beast hitter. I wouldn't do it.

[davdav]

help me!

viewtopic.php?t=412006

[Elsy]

I wouldn't do the AROD one either. Yes you are getting a great hitter but Morlaes will be close in numbers - 5 HR less, 10-15 less RBI and similar BA. Not gaining enough for what you are giving up.

[peartist]

How deep is your pitching? If giving up Price doesn't do any damage to your numbers (hard to believe, unless you have all of Sabathia, Greinke, Verlander, etc.), then do it. Just how 'excess' is your excess? If not, and you will take a decent hit, then don't do it. Longoria or A-Rod for Morales, if it can be boiled down to that depending on your pitching, IS something to go for. You do have to be aware of the guy your trading with, too, though, and where he is in the standings in relation to you.