Donnelly or K-Rod?

[Guest]

Who is better?

I would say Donnelly, but with him having that nose surgery I dont know how long he will be out. Does anyone know who would get the closer spot if Percival goes down?

I am trying to see who I need to drop because I am going to add Speier. Would you consider that a smart waiver move?

ps I know there have been some recent threads about both of these guys but I just wanted to see if some specific questions could be answered.

Thanks for your help!

[crapshooter]

I think they would go with K-Rod because the potential is so much greater on him

[stumpak]

Everything I read points to Donnelly if Percival goes down at some point, which is a good bet in its own right.

[Rohan]

It was donnely last year, but that was last year when percival went down for a little while