BIG One: Cl.Lee, Votto, WDavis for Prince, Sizemore, Hamels

[Super Manny]

Help me out, brethren, for this is a big one. I come to you seeking your expertise and guidance in hopes of once again reaching the glory of the fantasy promised land.

Yay or nay on the following deal, and your justification in believing so.

I GIVE:
Cliff Lee, SP
Joey Votto, 1B
Wade Davis, SP

I GET:
Cole Hamels, SP
Prince Fielder, 1B
Grady Sizemore, OF

League and team details are below:

12-team roto, 6x6
H categories - R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OBP
P categories - W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, HLD

Starters - 1 C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS; 3 OF; 1 UTIL
C - M. Wieters
1B - J. Votto
2B - Kelly Johnson, Brian Roberts (DL)
3B - A. Rodriguez
SS - J. Reyes
OF - BJ Upton, J. Ellsbury (DL), J. Bruce, C. Quentin, M. Stanton (NA)
UTIL - V. Guerrero

Starters - 5 SP; 4 RP
SP - C. Lee, F. Liriano, B. Anderson (DL), B. Webb (DL), S. Baker, B. Sheets, CJ Wilson, W. Davis, D. Holland
RP - B. Jenks, K. Wood, B. Lidge

Thanks in advance, and best of luck to each of you who take the time to read and weigh in.

[Carnac]

I would do this trade if I were you. Sizemore will give you more OF depth and Prince should be a force from here out. Hope he starts sooner than later. Your pitching is solid with Liriano, Baker, Sheets (starting to pitch well lately) and CJ.

good luck

help? viewtopic.php?t=411810

[bobellis75]

I disagree...I think you're giving up more than you're getting. Especially the pitching. I'm not sold on Grady (after last year and the start he's off to this year) and Hamels isn't anywhere near as good as Lee or Davis. Prince is a stud, and better than Votto...but I think you're only winning 1/3 of this deal.

If you have a second...trying to figure out what to do (if anything) with two offers I've received for Pujols.

viewtopic.php?t=411399

Appreciate any insight. Thanks.